Overall Favorite
Meineke Car Care Center
Highest combined score on this list.
- Operating status checked
New Haven · 2027 favorites
New Haven's favorite tire shops
5 favorites from 19 New Haven businesses, each labelled for what it does best.
- Updated
- How labels are set
The favorites
Start with these three
Labels aren't ranks: pick the one that fits your project.
Favorite
Midas
- Operating status checked
Customer Favorite
Star Tires Plus Wheels
The favorite customers talk about most.
- Operating status checked
More tire shops favorites in New Haven
- Torello Tire Company, Inc★ 4.7 · 354 reviews · East Haven
- Excelerate Performance★ 4.5 · 225 reviews · Branford
Also shortlisted
- Joanna's Truck Tire Service Llc★ 5.0 · 18 reviews · East Haven
- Whip-It Tire and Auto Repair★ 4.7 · 45 reviews · Branford
- Amity Motors★ 4.7 · 38 reviews · Woodbridge
- Porto's Tire Service★ 4.7 · 38 reviews · Hamden
- East Rock Auto Repair Inc★ 4.6 · 98 reviews · New Haven
- Lela and Matt's Car Care Clinic★ 4.6 · 28 reviews · Guilford
- United Tire Inc★ 4.6 · 14 reviews · Branford
- Monro Auto Service and Tire Centers★ 4.5 · 145 reviews · Woodbridge
- Aquila Motors★ 4.5 · 32 reviews · New Haven
- Monro Muffler Brake & Service★ 4.4 · 277 reviews · East Haven
- Access Auto Tires★ 4.4 · 54 reviews · New Haven
- Meineke Car Care Center★ 4.3 · 357 reviews · New Haven
- Town Fair Tire★ 4.3 · 248 reviews · Branford
- Precision Wheel Service★ 4.2 · 35 reviews · North Branford
Free quotes
Ask the favorites for a quote
Free, no account. Only the businesses you tick get your details.
Before you sign
Four things to check with any business
- Check the license with your state's licensing board.
- Get three itemised quotes so you compare like with like.
- Confirm who pulls the permit: it should be in the business's name.
- Tie payments to stages and get the warranty in writing.
Local facts
New Haven, by the numbers
Official figures behind the list.
7,425
People per square mile
Calculated from U.S. Census Bureau 2025 estimates and Gazetteer land area · 2025
18.7 sq mi
Land area
138,774
New Haven residents
U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates (sub-est2025) · July 1, 2025
+3.6%
Population change since 2020 (from 134,014 (April 2020 base))
U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2025 population estimates (sub-est2025) · 2020–2025
Questions
Tire shops in New Haven: common questions
How is the top 5 ranking of tire shops in New Haven calculated?
Each business gets a score from its rating, review volume, recent reviews, years in business, profile completeness and record checks. The highest scores make the list. We compared 19 tire shops for New Haven.
Which of these tire shops in New Haven has the best reviews?
Meineke Car Care Center has a 4.8 rating from 225 public reviews, the highest on this page.
Which of these tire shops has the most reviews?
Star Tires Plus Wheels, with 394 public reviews. A long review history shows how a business handles many jobs.
Are these tire shops licensed?
5 of the 5 businesses here had their state license checked against public records. Each profile shows the source and the date of the check.
How many quotes should I get for tire shops in New Haven?
Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request.